Annulment and enforcement in international arbitration is complex. A party can seek to delay or frustrate recovery by attacking an arbitral award on the same grounds at different jurisdictions and courts. Transnational Issue Estoppel is powerful and gaining tangible traction. Relative to international litigation, the doctrine operates in a nuanced fashion in international arbitration. The nuance is premised on the notion that decisions of seat and enforcement courts are not of equal standing such that seat court decisions carry (some level of) primacy. The precise contours are evolving and may never crystallise but the impact of Transnational Issue Estoppel is compelling and looks likely to increase. Jurisprudential analysis of contemporary caselaw in this Paper tends to conclude with several (defeasible) normative propositions that attempt to codify the current position.
ASA Bulletin