Adjudicating the Corrupted Record in International Arbitration - ASA Bulletin View Adjudicating the Corrupted Record in International Arbitration by - ASA Bulletin Adjudicating the Corrupted Record in International Arbitration 44 3

International arbitration is accustomed to deciding disputes on incomplete records. A different problem arises where a material evidential signal has been deliberately falsified, suppressed, or manipulated by a party or a person for whose conduct it is responsible. The resulting record is not merely incomplete: it is corrupted. This article develops a procedural response to that condition. It uses marine-insurance disputes in the sanctions era as its principal illustration, where vessel identity, location, cargo provenance, and the lawful character of relevant conduct may depend on electronic and documentary signals susceptible to manipulation. The argument is not that arbitral tribunals should alter substantive insurance, sanctions, or other legal rules. It is that tribunals and parties should design procedure to preserve evidence, distinguish unreliability from culpable corruption, test analytical evidence, and allocate the evidential consequences of proven manipulation without impermissibly reversing substantive burdens of proof.

ASA Bulletin