This article discusses the underlying advantages and disadvantages of construction adjudication identified by leading commentators by reference to (1) the key characteristics of the construction industry and dispute resolution in Hong Kong that make adjudication relevant, (2) a literature review of ‘textbook examples’ of the pros and cons of adjudication, and (3) interviews with distinguished industry practitioners. Based on his findings, the author critically evaluates the extent to which those ‘textbook examples’ apply to Hong Kong.