Unshell failed, but the June 2026 proposal for a recast of the Directive on Administrative Cooperation would move the EU debate on shell entities into the regime of mandatory disclosure: under the proposed Article 52, the substance criteria of DAC6 Hallmark D2 limbs (a) and (b) would be specified in a Council implementing act. This article asks what that act may legitimately contain, using the founder-managed company formed under Estonia’s e-Residency programme as a stress test: physically thin, yet with an identifiable natural person as beneficial owner.
The pattern shows why the indicators based on physical substance inherited from Unshell are unreliable evidence of abuse; and primary law, including Article 291(2) TFEU and the ‘essential elements’ doctrine, would preclude the act from converting D2 into a general low-substance reporting trigger. The article therefore proposes a functional framework: preserve D2’s cumulative structure; state expressly that remote incorporation, outsourcing and lack of local premises or staff are not enough; assess substance by reference to real activity, control and fiscal risk; and protect transparent digital businesses through clear safe harbours tied to active income and identifiable beneficial ownership.
EC Tax Review