Community Heat and EU Energy Law: Bridging the Institutional Gap - European Energy and Environmental Law Review View Community Heat and EU Energy Law: Bridging the Institutional Gap by - European Energy and Environmental Law Review Community Heat and EU Energy Law: Bridging the Institutional Gap 35 5

Heating accounts for a substantial share of EU emissions, yet the legal framework for energy communities established under the Clean Energy Package is designed primarily around electricity markets and prosumer participation, leaving community ownership of heat infrastructure legally under-specified. This article examines the extent to which EU energy law enables community ownership in the heating sector and how Member States have developed institutional mechanisms to operationalize thermal energy communities in practice. Doctrinal analysis of the relevant directives and emerging case law is combined with a comparative study of Denmark, Germany, and the Netherlands, structured around three institutional drivers: municipal heat planning, ownership and cooperative governance, and price regulation. The analysis shows that thermal energy communities emerge where national frameworks treat heat networks as collectively governed monopoly infrastructure – through planning authority, settled ownership rules, and cost-based pricing – rather than through the extension of prosumer rights. This misalignment also carries distributive consequences, as the prosumer paradigm favours households with capacity to invest, whereas collective-infrastructure models deliver regulated tariffs to all connected consumers. The article concludes that EU law should explicitly recognize community heat networks and integrate energy communities into heat planning and infrastructure governance, adopting differentiated approaches for electricity and heat.

European Energy and Environmental Law Review