The Governance Trilemma: Energy Security, Market Liberalization, and Decarbonization in EU Law - European Energy and Environmental Law Review View The Governance Trilemma: Energy Security, Market Liberalization, and Decarbonization in EU Law by - European Energy and Environmental Law Review The Governance Trilemma: Energy Security, Market Liberalization, and Decarbonization in EU Law 35 5

The European Union’s (EU’s) legally binding climate commitments sit in structural tension with its persistent reliance on fossil fuels, a tension that existing scholarship misdiagnoses as political hypocrisy rather than institutional design. No study has yet integrated EU constitutional energy law, the EU Taxonomy framework, and the private law of liquefied natural gas (LNG) procurement to explain why this tension is architecturally entrenched. This article argues that EU energy law embeds a governance trilemma: the simultaneous full achievement of energy security, market liberalization, and decarbonization is structurally precluded by three legal pillars. Employing a doctrinal-institutional methodology supplemented by empirical trade data from 2021 to 2026, the article demonstrates that Article 194(2) TFEU functions as an active veto instrument, that the General Court’s judgment in Austria v. Commission (Case T-625/22) institutionalizes energy security as a Taxonomy classification variable, and that Regulation (EU) 2026/261 legally entrenches gas dependency until at least November 2027. The article proposes three structural reforms: extending qualified majority voting (QMV) via the passerelle clause, integrating climate-conditionality into LNG procurement contracts, and enacting a binding sunset clause for natural gas under the Taxonomy framework.

European Energy and Environmental Law Review