The
increasing digitalization of commercial transactions has transformed the nature
of evidentiary systems in both litigation and arbitration. Electronic proof now
constitutes a central component of contemporary commercial disputes, yet it
raises complex legal questions concerning authenticity, reliability, and
procedural fairness. This article undertakes a comparative doctrinal analysis
of the UNCITRAL framework and the European Union’s eIDAS Regulation to examine
how electronic evidence is regulated in cross-border commercial transactions.
The study argues that
although both systems aim to facilitate legal recognition of electronic
communications, significant structural limitations remain, particularly in
relation to evidentiary asymmetry created by organizational control over
digital infrastructures. The interaction between regulatory certainty and data
governance further complicates the admissibility and evaluation of electronic
evidence
By integrating comparative
legal analysis with contemporary evidentiary theory, the article demonstrates
that electronic proof is no longer governed solely by traditional procedural
rules but by a multi-layered governance structure combining commercial law,
regulatory compliance, and digital trust frameworks